Fort Collins Crate Guide

Before you pay

Buying used vinyl

A used record can sound as good as new or barely play. Two minutes with the disc out of its sleeve tells you which.

The two-minute check

  1. Hold it by the edge and the label. The Library of Congress care guidance says to handle grooved discs by the edge and label areas only. Fingerprints in the grooves attract dust.
  2. Tilt it under a light. Slight scuffs and very light scratches are allowed on a VG+ copy. A scratch deep enough to feel with a fingernail is a VG fault that will be heard.
  3. Sight along the edge. Hold the record at eye level and turn it slowly. A slight warp can play fine; a badly warped record may skip.
  4. Look at the grooves. Visible groove wear goes with surface noise, and on a heavily played copy it will be there in the quiet passages.
  5. Check the label and centre hole. An oval or chewed hole means heavy play. Writing or stickers on the label lower the grade but not the sound.
  6. Check the sleeve separately. Seam splits, water stains and ring wear matter if you collect covers, less if you only want to listen.

What the grades mean

Most US shops and online sellers use the grading scale published by Goldmine magazine. The disc and the cover are graded separately, so a sticker may read "VG+/VG". These summaries follow the excerpt of the Goldmine guide published by Jazz Collector.

GradeWhat you should expect
Mint (M)Never played, possibly still sealed. Used sparingly, if at all.
Near Mint (NM, M-)No obvious signs of wear on the disc; the jacket has no creases, splits or cut-out marks.
Very Good Plus (VG+)Played by a careful owner. Slight scuffs or very light scratches that don't affect listening; slight warps that don't affect the sound are allowed.
Very Good (VG)Surface noise is audible in quiet passages and intros, but doesn't overpower the music. Light scratches you can feel.
Good (G, G+)Plays through without skipping, with significant surface noise and visible wear.
Poor (P), Fair (F)Cracked, badly warped or skips. Buy only for the cover, or if you can't find another copy.

Grading is a judgement call, and two shops can grade the same copy differently. If a copy matters to you, ask to hear it.

New pressings

If a new record plays badly, the shop's returns policy decides what happens next. Ask about it before you open the shrink wrap, and keep the receipt.

When you get it home

Swap a paper inner sleeve for a polyethylene one and store the record upright. Our record care page has the details.