Clearing the shelves
Selling a record collection in Fort Collins
All four shops in this guide buy used records. How they do it differs, so read this before you load the car.
We don't buy records. The details below come from each shop's website, checked on 17 November 2026. Buying hours and policies change; check the shop's site first.
Who buys, and how
Drop-off
All Sales Vinyl
Takes collections seven days a week during opening hours, preferring weekdays. You leave the records and your contact details, they go into a queue, and the shop calls back with an offer on the titles it wants. Records it doesn't buy can be returned or donated. Consignment only for rare or valuable items. Its selling page has the full FAQ.
Collections
Driver 8 Records
Buys collections of all sizes across many genres, says its homepage, which lists a phone number and email for sellers.
Buy, sell, trade
Bizarre Bazaar
Buys or trades records, CDs, tapes and stereo gear during set buying hours. On our check it was not buying on Tuesdays or Thursdays; its homepage lists the current days.
Ask at the bar
Intersect Brewing
Buys used records through its record buyer; its records page says to call the taproom to connect.
How shops price a collection
All Sales Vinyl says it inspects every record for scratches, warping, sleeve condition and playability, and checks past online sales to set a value. Expect any shop to work the same way: the price depends on condition and on what the record sells for, not on what it cost new.
A shop has to resell what it buys, so its offer will be below the price you'd see on the shelf. Selling copies one at a time online may bring in more, but then the grading, photographing, packing and shipping are all yours.
Before you bring them in
- Sort out the obvious losers. Cracked discs and records with deep scratches rarely get an offer.
- Keep inserts with their records. Lyric sheets, posters and original inner sleeves belong in the jacket.
- Pull anything you might regret selling. Once it's in the queue, it's harder to get one record back.
- Carry them upright. Sturdy boxes, filled so the records can't lean, and not left in a hot car.